This posting just leaves me speechless. Because of the lack of paragraphs, I've parsed through this mess and highlighted the most amusing sections.
http://groups.google.com/group/wattage/msg/561b04090955b817?I wanted to start a new discussion so it doesn't get lost in the shuffle. First, a little background disclosure:
What I am-totally committed avid cyclist who logs 10,000 miles/500,000'+ of climbing per year, non-racer except the occasional TT, but I do lead one of the hardest group rides in my area.. What I am not-pro cyclist, scientist, engineer. I've been reading the wattage forums much longer than I have been using my ibike, so maybe I'm not qualified enough, and deserving enough, to throw this post out there, but here are my observations: First let me say, I have really enjoyed the numerous great training tips and superb advice I have derived from this site. I only wish that was the major focus of the group. What I have been able to gather about devices, is that there is no perfect power meter, and the only consistent talk about power meters revolves around the inconsistency of the imperfections and limitations. Now back to the ibike. For me, it's real simple. If, at the end of a ride, I simply dropped my bike on the ground across the finish line, and said to my mechanic, "Have it ready for tomorrow's stage", I would have an SRM Pro, if for no other reason, that than it "seems" to be the best, and a lot of pros use it. Whether they get paid to is a good question, but my point is that I don't hand my bike to somebody, I either work on it, or pay somebody to, and I buy my equipment with my own money. Now,
if you were to see my bicycles and my kit, you would probably gather that I could afford multiple SRM Pros, and if I felt I needed one, or even wanted one, I would certainly have one. I want a more simple solution. I've been waiting for the ibike people to get the product dialed in, and I decided that they were close enough, so I went ahead and got the wireless unit. I'm willing to accept thelimitations of the ibike because they are far outweighed by the advantages, and for me, in my world,
99% of the time it generates not only highly repeatable numbers, but accurate ones if I compare it to my power based trainer I've used for years now, mostly for fitness testing. Now, I'll try my hand at predicting the future. I have never experienced customer service at the level of the ibike, and certainly not from the top level of a company. Richard Wharton and John Hammand seem to be available 24 hours a day. I don't think anybody works that hard unless they know they have something very special, so
here is how I think the story ends: ibike does really get it dialed in, so much so, that, guess what, it becomes good enough for people like me and most of you. There are a lot more of us than there are professional world class cyclists. A large sports equipment company buys ibike out, spends a lot of dough on marketing, and within 2 years, they have a majority market share, if not a near monopoly, of the power meter market. At this point, the ibike people laugh as they trot off to the bank. I'm guessing the thing most likely to drerail this track is the introduction of an even simpler and/or less expensive alternative to the ibike, not another product costing many multiples more, and offering yet another set of unique limitations and disadvantages. And I imagine at that point I'll be mad that I didn't wait for this new "better" product, and I'll join in with all of you, and bash a product I have not even tried! My point is, if you haven't ascertained it already, that most people want a simple, not complex solution for measuring their power. For me, the ibike is that solution.
RebuttalYes, we're all very impressed by your 10,000 mi/yr and 500,000' of virtual climbing.
You bought an iBike because you thought an SRM would require too much effort to use? The same iBike that iBike users have described as having a calibration procedure equivalent to a space shuttle launch? The iBike that customers feel they are beta testing because it has so many problems?
You calibrated your iBike using the most inaccurate power measuring devices of all, indoor trainers? This would have been interesting since the iBike doesn't actually work indoors.
A near monopoly of the powermeter market? This is truly delusional.
A monopoly that can only be derailed by a cheaper and simpler powermeter? That would be the basic PowerTap. Much, much simpler. Less expensive and much more accurate.